• Achievers Facebook Page  Achievers Twitter Page  Achievers Google plus Page  Achievers Telegram Page
#1360, 2nd floor, Marenhalli, 100ft road,
Jayanagar 9th Block, Bangalore-560069.
IAS Coaching in Bangalore
Home » BUILDING RESILIENCE TO CYCLONES

BUILDING RESILIENCE TO CYCLONES

BUILDING RESILIENCE TO CYCLONES

GS 3, MAINS: Disaster and disaster management.

  • As Odisha lies battered by the fury of cyclone Fani and limps back to normalcy from the devastating trail of the extremely severe cyclone, the state draws accolade for being disaster ready.
  • Most efficient, timely and well-planned large-scale evacuation and early warnings have saved many lives, especially of the poor and marginalised living on the edge of this sensitive coastal ecosystem. While this efficient emergency response sets an example for other vulnerable states, it also signals the need to prioritise climate-resilient infrastructure and buildings to minimise the humungous cost of reconstruction. 
  • Horrifying visuals of collapsing structures, mobile towers and cranes in Puri and Bhubaneswar, thatched houses being blown away in coastal areas and ripped roads, remind us once again of the importance of building climate-resilient structures.

BUILDING SENSE:

  • Cyclones and earthquakes don’t kill but buildings do. Bhubaneswar and Puri have seen how winds gushing at 120-145 kilometres per hour (kmph) have ripped off super structures, soft roofs and window frames in modern buildings and flying objects caused havoc.  
  • There is a national guidance in the Model Building Byelaws 2016 of the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs that provides for ‘climate-resilient construction: integration of environmental clearances with sanction’. This has asked for risk classification of buildings and climate-resilient construction to protect structures. While this provision may still be revisited to assess its adequacy to withstand the pressure of wind that can soar to 200 kmph during storm surge, its adoption at the local level must happen quickly.
  • Unfortunately, most big cities in vulnerable coastal states have not yet fully aligned with its provisions. At the same time, small and medium towns often do not have adequate byelaws. In the absence of proper regulatory and compliance framework and mechanism, haphazard and hazardous development takes place that causes serious loss to life and property when disaster strikes.

BUILDING FOR POOR PEOPLE:

  • Fani’s trail of destruction has also exposed the vulnerability of thatched, mud and bamboo houses the poor live in. But the obvious answer to this is not substitution by ill-designed brick, mortar and concrete housing. We have seen innovative architectural design and material innovation in coastal Tamil Nadu and other places where post-Tsunami, architects like Durganand Balswar have built affordable and resilient brick structures for rehabilitation of the displaced.

  • But it is important to reinvent the low-cost and sustainable material for the poor. Thatch and bamboo are widely and cheaply available in these ecosystems. Architects say while thatch cannot resist super cyclone category, which is above 180-200 kmph, these can be well-crafted and adapted to resist at least 160 kmph with easier possibilities of rebuilding.
  • These materials will remain dominant in rural and peri-urban areas of these ecosystems — not only for the housing of the poor but can also be a material of choice for the rich. If this material is not absorbed in construction it will be burnt to cause toxic pollution.
  • Materials are not bad, but it is the poor workmanship and lack of knowledge of locally appropriate architecture based on local material in vulnerable areas that is enhancing the risk for the majority. Even the performance of semi-engineered RCC frames — the most dominant technique today — can be compromised if not designed well.
  • Policies will have to ensure access to improved knowledge and craftsmanship of traditional techniques, involve professional architects in dissemination of this knowledge and provide policy support for more diverse and locally appropriate techniques for the marginalised in vulnerable coast lines.

CLIMATE RESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE:

  • Fani is also the lasting reminder of how climate-resilient infrastructure is needed to reduce long-term costs of redevelopment and restoration. During intense storm surge vulnerable regions are susceptible to instantaneous damage to infrastructure. These regions need quick adoption of design standards to withstand storms, and adapt to high wind speed, heavy rain and flooding to reduce damage.

 

  • Indian Road Congress guidelines, which govern road design, are being revised for adoption of climate resilient guidelines for roads and drainage. This is considering resilient design standards and material for road infrastructure. Road-building will have to be aligned with improved drainage system. Street design, mobility alignment, and public transport will have to reflect special needs during climatic stress.
  • Design guidelines will also have to improve and augment drainage capacity and link it with water recharge and storage. Flood risk assessment and flood plain management must also be mandatory. Assessment of vulnerability can govern development along shore line and vulnerable areas to enhance protection and hedge risk.

LEARNING FROM GLOBAL CITIES:

  • Increasingly, high-growth and populous urban centres are becoming more vulnerable to climate vagaries. Globally, coastal cities are taking lead to build climate resilient infrastructure. Hong Kong and Copenhagen are managing flooding during extreme heavy rainfall in low-lying delta cities.
  • Hong Kong has overhauled its drainage infrastructure. It has innovatively implemented Happy Valley Underground Stormwater Storage Scheme, constructing beneath several sports fields.
  • Copenhagen is using the method of “fight flooding with flooding” by lowering its parks and raising sidewalks connected to parks. During extreme downpours, the parks will turn into temporary reservoirs and storage for recharge while the streets will channelize water towards the city’s harbour. 
  • Singapore has adopted storm water and flood management during extreme weather events. It adopted source-pathway-receptor approach using green roofs, rain gardens or retention ponds to slow down the flow of storm water discharged from buildings into the drainage system. It also manages storm water discharge through widening and deepening of drains and canals, as well as construction of flood barriers. It is addressing future sea level rise.

PREVIOUS YEARS UPSC MAINS QUESTIONS:

  • Describe various measures taken in India for Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) before and after signing ‘Sendai Framework for DRR (2015-2030)’. How is this framework different from ‘Hyogo Framework for Action, 2005’? (2018)
  • On December 2004, tsunami brought havoc on fourteen countries including India. Discuss the factor responsible for occurrence of tsunami and its effects on life and economy. In the light of guidelines of NDMA (2010) describe the mechanisms for preparedness to reduce the risk during such events. (2017)
  • The frequency of urban floods due to high intensity rainfall is increasing over the years. Discussing the reasons for urban floods. highlight the mechanisms for preparedness to reduce the risk during such events. (2016)
  • With reference to National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) guidelines, discuss the measures to be adopted to mitigate the impact of the recent incidents of cloudbursts in many places of Uttarakhand. (2016)
  • The frequency of earthquakes appears to have increased in the Indian subcontinent. However, India’s preparedness for mitigating their impact has significant gaps. Discuss various aspects. (2015)
  • Drought has been recognized as a disaster in view of its spatial expanse, temporal duration, slow onset and lasting effects on vulnerable sections. With a focus on the September 2010 guidelines from the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), discuss the mechanisms for preparedness to deal with likely El Nino and La Nina fallouts in India. (2014)